May 10, 2021
Ontario’s ICI Permit Values Down 5% in Q1 Compared to Last Year
Statistics Canada’s latest building permit data update shows that ICI permit values in Ontario in the first quarter were down by 5.3% compared to the first quarter of 2020. ICI building permits in the province amounted to just over $3.8 billion in the quarter, while in Q1 2020, ICI permits were about $4 billion. The decline was led by Ontario’s commercial sector, which saw a drop-off in permit values of 17.8%. While permit values fell in the commercial sector, permit values increased in the first quarter in Ontario’s industrial and institutional sectors. Industrial permit values in the province increased by 18.7%, while institutional permits increased by 10.3%. This means that the trend observed in January and February – of commercial sector decline, and industrial and institutional increase – continued through March.
It should be noted that despite the declines in total ICI permit values and commercial permit values in Q1 2021, permit values are higher compared to Q1 2019 in all sectors. Overall, ICI permit values in the first quarter of this year were 9.3% greater than in the first quarter of 2019, with commercial permit values 7.4% greater, industrial 3.9% greater, and institutional 19.7% greater.
ICI permit values declined in the first quarter of 2021 in nine of Ontario’s metropolitan areas, and increased in seven. Toronto’s ICI permit values fell by 8.8% in Q1 2021 compared to Q1 2020, while Oshawa also had a single-digit decline of 7.7%. The next biggest year-over-year declines were in Kitchener-Cambridge Waterloo (-10.4%), Thunder Bay (-27.4%) and Greater Sudbury (-29.5). Q1 ICI permit values were down by about half in St. Catharines-Niagara (-48.3%), Windsor (-48.7%) and Guelph (-50.8%). Ottawa’s ICI permit values fell by 65.9% in Q1 2021 compared to the first quarter of 2020.
First quarter ICI permit values were up by double-digits over Q1 2020 in London (+22.3%), Barrie (+42.8%) and Belleville (+52.9%). Permit values more than doubled in Q1 2021 compared to Q1 2020 in Hamilton (+107.7%), Peterborough (116.8%), Brantford (117.7%) and Kingston (166.5%). These significant increases are due partly to these metro areas recording disproportionately low permit totals in Q1 2020. The increases in Hamilton and Brantford are also explained by permits issued for major industrial projects. The City of Hamilton issued a $120 million permit for a new Amazon warehouse facility in February, while an $18 million permit was issued by the City of Brantford in March for a new plant-based consumer products production facility.
Construction Employment Stable Despite Pandemic Disruptions
While the first months of 2021 have seen escalating lockdown and stay-at-home order conditions in Ontario, construction industry employment has so far been relatively stable. In the past six months, construction employment in Ontario has remained close to 540,000, not straying more than about one percent higher or lower. The biggest month-over-month change was a 2% increase between February and March of this year. While construction employment has been relatively stable, it is yet to return to pre-pandemic levels. In the first quarter of 2020, before the pandemic took hold, employment in Ontario’s construction industry averaged 561,000 compared to 538,000 in the first quarter of 2021.
The general unemployment rate for Ontario was 9.0% in April, up from 7.5% in March. Despite the escalating lockdown and stay-at-home order conditions, these are the two lowest monthly unemployment rates recorded in Ontario since the pandemic began.
It should be noted for both the unemployment rate and the construction employment data that the April Labour Force Survey reflects conditions during the week of April 11-17. This means that the data would capture the impact of the April 8 stay-at-home order, but not the strengthened stay-at-home order of April 16. The effects of the April 16 order will not be known until May’s Labour Force Survey data is released in early June.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, CONTACT:
Director of Research
Ontario Construction Secretariat (OCS)
180 Attwell Drive, Suite 360, Toronto, ON M9W 6A9
P 416.620.5210 ext. 222